Skip to main content

This Or That: Colorbar I-Glide Pencils vs Faces Long Wear Pencils

It has always been a bone of contention whether the Colorbar I-Glide Pencils were the ones to go for or whether the Faces Long Wear pencils fare better. Of course both are dear to us beauty bloggers and to all beauty enthusiasts but seriously sometimes even I am at a loss at what I should really go for. Both ranges of pencils have similar shades and similar staying power even on oily lids, so getting confused between the two is an expected deal :)


Hence, I am trying to make an endeavor to make it easier for everyone of us to finally make a decision where these two pencils are concerned :)

Similarities


Property
Colorbar I-Glide & Faces Long Wear Pencils
Staying Power
They have similar staying power. They stay on for more than 8 hours easily.
Performance on Oily Lids
They both stay on and do not transfer or smudge on oily lids. I have super oily lids and I vouch for them both
Texture
Both are super smooth texture-wise and glide on like a dream!
Availability
With Faces stores open nationwide plus with the advent of various online beauty portals, availability of both is not an issue.
Ease of Removal
Both are waterproof but can easily removed with soap or makeup remover. No tugging, no scrubbing :)

Differences


Property
Colorbar I-Glide Pencils
Faces Long Wear Pencils
Price
They cost Rs. 375/- per pencil
They cost Rs.249/- per pencil
Quantity
Each pencils weighs 1.1 gms
Each pencil weighs 1.5 gms
Color Selection
Decent range of shades available
The range of shades available in this pencil is a tad bit more that those of the Colorbar ones :)

Verdict
Though the competition was really close, Faces Long Wear Pencils win by a slight margin mostly on the basis of the cost of the pencils :) Other than that it is super difficult to judge on the better pencil :)

What is your take on it?

Comments

  1. Faces ones for me..I totally love them..colorbar has become even more expensive re its 399 now

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They increased prices for I-Glides too? These pencils were already on the expensive side and now its almost 400 bucks? LOL.. what are they even trying to do?

      Delete
  2. Both of these are so similar....Sad!!! Colorbar lost because of price factor...The I-glide pencils look prettier than the faces one though

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. hahahah yeah the silver colored pencils tend to be very eye catching :) though i like the black sleek looking Faces pencil ka look as well :)

      Delete
  3. I adore the faces one . . . havent used colorbar but i dont want to spend 400 bucks on a similar product !!!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hands down Faces for me! colorbar have increased prices for most of their products dont know where they are going with that :P

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i swear! I see no logic in increasing prices for everything! Even MAC is doing that! I think they are following the petrol prices ka trend :P

      Delete
  5. thanks for comparison post, it is really difficult for us to get these in our place

    ReplyDelete
  6. yay!am gonna hoard more faces pencils now..thanku Suma..:)

    ReplyDelete
  7. colorbar is hiking price every 3 months I guess! For me, its faces when it comes to these pencils!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i know! I wonder why they keep doing that! As such I really like Colorbar but the price hikes are really putting me off! :(

      Delete
  8. I love both!but colorbar keeps hiking its prices un necessarily.. Idiots!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Woww liked your post! Loved the way you compared! Totally agree with all points you mentioned!

    ReplyDelete
  10. i love faces eye pencils..will buy some more shades ^____^
    but man! colorbar is increasing prices like crazy! heard their blushes are now Rs.575..wth !O.o

    ReplyDelete
  11. Replies
    1. happy to help :) Oh god that sounded sooo Vodafone! :P

      Delete
  12. So true, totally agree with that. I recently tried the Avon glimmerstick, even those are fabulous and no sharpening required but they totally lack variety in shades :(

    ReplyDelete
  13. nice comparision..havent tried both the brands.this will help me decide.

    ReplyDelete
  14. That brought fond memories of school class work where we used to tabulate diff n similarities :) lol.. beauty is serious stuff.. and it will be the faces one for me also..

    http://thebeautydoctorspeaks.blogspot.in/2012/06/beauty-myths-and-facts-solved.html

    ReplyDelete
  15. hi der plz join my blog..i hav join yours...

    ReplyDelete
  16. I like the faces ones hands down, I feel their texture & quality is much better and they also seem more pigmented to me as compared to colorbar.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I recently came across ur blog n i have to say i totally love it..i love ur style of writing ...and thanks for the detailed comparison..i face the exact same dilemna whn it comes to them..but bcoz of colorbar constantly increasing their prices im turning to faces more n more..absolutely love the sheen of their navy blue eye pencil

    ReplyDelete
  18. super useful post! Thanks for doing all the hard work! :)

    ReplyDelete
  19. I bought my first i-glide pencil in Cocobar 02 just yesterday and now I know why there is so much of craze for this i-glide colorbar pencil in the Indian beauty blog world! I am loving it!

    www.crazypoplock.com

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Make Me Happy :) Leave A Comment!

Popular posts from this blog

Cover The Cover: Harper's Bazaar (India) March 2012

You all know that I love tweaking my blog here and there and making some changes, introducing newer features and well sometimes just hooking the blog onto some social networking site :) Well this time I am introducing a new feature that I promise will be really exciting for all beauty enthusiasts :) To start with this feature is called "Cover The Cover" where I shall be covering the cover pages of our favorite beauty and fashion magazines in terms of make-up. There are times when a certain look on a celeb or a fashion mag just gets to us. Well rather than just mulling over such looks I have decided to give life to such looks (on me) and well do a kind of a faux photo shoot ;) What say? Doesn't it sound like fun? What more? You are all invited to submit your looks with a reference to which magazine and edition you are covering and I'll post it here :)

Today's look is inspired by my latest fav mag Harper's Bazaar. The March edition of Harper's Bazaar is a …

REVIEW: L'Oreal Paris Infallible Blush Paint Longwear High Impact Stick - Fuchsia Fame

Review of L'Oreal Paris Infallible Blush Paint Longwear High Impact Stick - Fuchsia Fame
Right now am sitting at the dining table trying to figure out a way to start this post in an "interesting" way... I am obviously struggling... There are these times when your mind just goes blank and you can't think of anything, right? Yeah, I am having one of those moments...

So, I guess I'll directly dive into the review and not mull around. I bought the L'Oreal Paris Infallible Blush Paint Stick on a whim... I was out window shopping at Shoppers Stop and I just happened to glance at the L'Oreal counter and this cute little stub caught my fancy... The moment I swatched it I knew I had to buy it...




Price of L'Oreal Paris Infallible Blush Paint Stick It costs a whopping INR 999/-

There is nothing much to talk about the packaging. It is exactly what it looks like, a rotating chubby stick with a cap. The plastic doesn't seem cheap and is pretty sturdy. I have d…

REVIEW & LOTD: Faces Long Wear Pencil in Navy Blue

While doing the "Meet The Bloggers" feature every Saturday, I have realised (and I am sure that you all have too) that Faces is fast becoming a very popular brand amongst us especially the Faces Long Wear pencils. So much so that a lot of people prefer Faces Long Wear pencils to even Colorbar I-Glides and that ladies and gentlemen is quite a feat for a newly launched brand. So anyways, I got myself a "Navy Blue" from this range and I must say that I am very happy with it. This is my second pencil from Faces after "Turquoise Blue" and well it hasn't failed me either.
This particular shade is a beautiful deep blue that looks stunning on the eye lids.
Image of the Product Swatches LOTD

Ooooohss And Aaahhss!! 1. Really really stays on forever. 2. Doesn't smudge on my oily lids even after 8 hours of wear. 3. Friendly to the pocket 4. Faces have become quite easily available now. 5. They do not cause any allergies or reactions. 6. They are waterline safe a…